November 26, 2023

The Next Leap Forward in AI Storytelling: Insight over Intuition

Charting the course of AI: from intuitive responses to thoughtful narratives

Today's discussion takes us into the heart of a riveting topic in the AI world, particularly the field of AI story development. As we edge closer to 2024, the anticipation builds for what could be a landmark year in this domain. The evolving landscape of AI is not just a technical progression; it's a narrative revolution waiting to unfold.

The Current State: Preconscious AI Minds

Let's start with where we are now. Inspired by Andrej Karpathy's enlightening introduction to Large Language Models (LLMs), we've gained a fascinating perspective. Our current AI, akin to a 'System 1 mind' or what we in the narrative sphere call the 'Preconscious', operates on intuition. When you toss a prompt at it, the AI swiftly, almost instinctively, crafts a response. It's impressive, yes, but it's just skimming the surface of potential.

(And for those familiar with the Preconscious in narrative theory, these AIs dredge up a fair amount of Confidence issues—with just a bit of Worry thrown in for fair measure!)

The Exciting Future: Conscious AI Minds

Now, brace yourselves for the thrilling part – the next wave, possibly unfurling in 2024. We're talking about an evolution from Preconscious systems to 'Conscious' ones (yet another specific area of narrative theory). Imagine AI not just reacting, but contemplating, assessing, and reassessing your narrative queries. This isn't just prompt engineering; it's akin to nurturing a 'System 2 mind', a more deliberate and analytical approach.

(Again for those familiar with Subtxt/Dramatica theory, the area of Conscious naturally brings to mind issues of Investigation, Appraisal, and Re-appraisals—exactly what they’re hopeful about with these System 2 minds)

Why This Matters for Subtxt and Dramatica

For all of us who revel in the depths of Subtxt and Dramatica theory, this shift is more than just technical jargon. It's about enriching the way stories are developed. Currently, our AI companions respond with confidence and speed, but they're missing a layer of depth – the kind that comes from careful consideration and a more nuanced understanding of narrative complexities.

The emphasis on the Preconscious for now may engender a lot of Progress in our relationship between human and AI (Progress is the natural focus of inequity in a relationship when attention is on the Preconscious), yet we will only truly become Present and fully able to do our best work in collaboration with AI once we shift to the Conscious (Present being the relationship focus in Conscious plot narrative).

The API of Tomorrow: Thinking, Not Just Responding

Here's where it gets even more exciting. The next-gen AI could offer an API that goes beyond mere responses. It would take a moment to 'think' through your narrative challenges, meticulously working through each step before presenting you with a well-considered solution. This approach harnesses 'test time compute', a concept where the AI uses its processing power not just to answer quickly but to answer wisely.

(Almost certainly positive this is what all the hubbub was about with the recent OpenAI drama in mid-November 2023).

What This Means for Storytellers

For us storytellers, writers, and narrative enthusiasts, this evolution could be a game-changer. Imagine an AI that doesn't just spit out a plot point but helps you weave a story with depth, character arcs that resonate, and themes that linger long after the tale is told. I mean, truth be told, Subtxt already does this—which is why its current responses are so prescient and insightful. But if you can imagine a world where Subtxt extends it’s current abilities and can now take more time to fully develop the intricacies involved in each of these narrative arcs and dynamics—that’s when things get interesting for us storytellers.

We're looking at a future where AI becomes more of an active collaborator than a passive writing tool—an extension of our consciousness—and a partner in crafting narratives that touch hearts and provoke thought.

The Speed of Thinking

In our journey into the realm of AI story development, it's essential to acknowledge the roots of the System 1 and System 2 concept. This idea was brilliantly introduced by Daniel Kahneman in his influential book, "Thinking, Fast and Slow." Kahneman, a Nobel laureate, delves into the dual-process theory of the mind. System 1 represents our intuitive, rapid-response thinking, often operating subconsciously. System 2, on the other hand, is our analytical, deliberate mode of thought, stepping in for more complex reasoning tasks. This fascinating dichotomy not only reshapes our understanding of human psychology but also deeply influences modern AI development, particularly in the way we envision narrative AI evolving from quick, intuitive responses to more thoughtful, considered storytelling.

(Editor’s note: AI wrote the above paragraph, erroneously labeling System 1 as Subconscious instead of Preconscious. In narrative theory, the Subconscious is drives, desires, and ego—not at all what Kahneman was getting at in his book. All the more reason to study and learn narrative theory!)

Wrapping Up: The Future Is Almost Here

As we stand at the brink of this new era in AI story development, the anticipation is palpable. This transition from Preconscious to Conscious AI minds signifies not just a technological advancement but a transformative shift in storytelling capabilities. We're on the verge of seeing AI evolve from a mere tool to a collaborative partner, capable of crafting narratives with greater depth and resonance. The future of AI story development is almost upon us, and we’re happy to take advantage of every new leap forward as we continue to develop Subtxt and Subtxt Muse.

Download the FREE e-book Never Trust a Hero

Don't miss out on the latest in narrative theory and storytelling with artificial intelligence. Subscribe to the Narrative First newsletter below and receive a link to download the 20-page e-book, Never Trust a Hero.